playrote.play.v1

mmodiqo/second-opinionv0.1.1Public

Second opinion

Cross-examines one AI coding assistant's answer with a different assistant.

Read the full description

Asks the first for a conclusion plus reasoning, gives the second the original question, the same material and the first answer, and asks whether it holds up and which single claim it would challenge first. Leads with the disagreement, then the verdict, then both reasonings. Refuses to run both roles as the same assistant.

  • Published 17 Aug 2026
  • Downloads 7
  • Needs rote 0.62.0+
  • Digest sha256:217283ec74f0…
  • Reference modiqo/second-opinion@0.1.1

Before you run it4 local tools

Everything here is checked on your machine when rote inspects the play. This page never learns what you have installed or which credentials you hold.

  • ○
    python3local tool

    Must be on your PATH. rote reports what it finds during inspect.

  • ○
    claudelocal tool

    Must be on your PATH. rote reports what it finds during inspect.

  • ○
    codexlocal tool

    Must be on your PATH. rote reports what it finds during inspect.

  • ○
    geminilocal tool

    Must be on your PATH. rote reports what it finds during inspect.

Inputs5, 1 required

rote asks for these before running and shows the defaults it will use.

  • Questionquestion

    The question to put to both assistants, in your own words.

    requiredstringcustom value allowed
  • Materialmaterial

    Optional path to a file, diff or directory. Both assistants are given read access and are told to open it themselves.

    optionalstringcustom value allowed
  • Answer withanswer_with

    Assistant that answers first (claude, codex or gemini). Chosen automatically when omitted.

    optionalstringcustom value allowed
  • Checked bychecked_by

    Assistant that checks the first answer. Must differ from answer_with; chosen automatically when omitted.

    optionalstringcustom value allowed
  • Timeout secondstimeout_seconds

    Per-assistant wall-clock budget in seconds.

    optionalstringdefault 600custom value allowed

What it changes

No write operations are declared in this version's manifest.

Credentials remain in the recipient's local rote vault; this page and the publisher never receive them.

Runtime details
  • rote CLIversion 0.62.0 or newer
  • Servicesnone declared
  • Digestsha256:217283ec74f0f440803159b82cfc54476a81591de49e18b3e3c1d386497597f6
  • Archive size21419 bytes
  • Published2026-08-17T23:58:21.222529+00:00
  • Published withrote 0.69.0

Credential values and current readiness remain local. Opening this page never prompts for a credential, opens an authorization browser, or calls a service this play uses.

A play is a published, versioned automation package that runs on your own machine through rote, a free command-line tool. Opening this page installs nothing and runs nothing.